Back to Blog

Why Does Tennis Elbow Keep Coming Back? Understanding Chronic Elbow Pain

2026-06-26 5 min read
Medically Reviewed by Dr. Marisa Formica, MD · June 26, 2026

Tennis elbow can frustrate anyone who wants to return to work, sports, or daily tasks without pain. Many patients in Forest Hills and surrounding areas find that symptoms return even after initial relief. Understanding the reasons behind recurring elbow pain helps you take the right steps toward lasting improvement.

What Is Tennis Elbow and Why It Becomes Chronic

Tennis elbow, or lateral epicondylitis, involves irritation of the tendons that attach to the outer elbow. Repetitive gripping, lifting, or wrist extension often triggers the condition. When these tendons do not heal fully, inflammation and small tears persist, leading to chronic discomfort.

Patients in Queens frequently report that symptoms flare during routine activities like typing or carrying bags. Dr. Mehran Manouel, an orthopedic surgeon with extensive experience in sports medicine, notes that incomplete tendon recovery is a common reason pain returns. Addressing both the tendon damage and the underlying movement patterns offers better long-term results.

Common Causes of Recurring Elbow Pain

Overuse remains the leading trigger, yet several factors keep the cycle going. Poor ergonomics at a workstation, inadequate warm-up before activity, or sudden increases in training intensity can overload healing tissue. Weak forearm muscles and improper technique during sports also contribute to repeated strain.

In Great Neck and Long Island communities, many active adults juggle work demands with weekend sports. This combination often prevents full recovery between episodes. Dr. Marisa Formica, who specializes in non-surgical orthopedics, emphasizes evaluating daily habits alongside the injury itself to break the pattern of recurrence.

Recognizing Symptoms That Signal a Persistent Issue

Sharp pain on the outer elbow that worsens with gripping or lifting usually appears first. Stiffness after rest, tenderness when pressing the bony area, and reduced grip strength often follow. When these symptoms last beyond a few weeks or return quickly after rest, the condition has likely moved into a chronic phase.

Some patients notice radiating discomfort into the forearm or wrist. Early recognition allows for timely intervention before the tendon develops more significant degeneration. Tracking which movements provoke pain helps guide an effective care plan.

How Specialists Evaluate Chronic Tennis Elbow

A thorough evaluation begins with a detailed history of symptoms and activities. Physical tests assess tendon tenderness, grip strength, and elbow stability. Imaging such as ultrasound or MRI may be used when symptoms persist despite conservative care.

At the Forest Hills location, Dr. Manouel and Dr. Formica review each case together to identify contributing factors like neck or shoulder issues that can refer pain to the elbow. This comprehensive approach helps distinguish simple overuse from more complex problems that require targeted treatment.

Treatment Options for Long-Lasting Relief

Initial care often includes activity modification, specific stretching, and strengthening exercises. Bracing or physical therapy can reduce tendon stress during daily tasks. When symptoms continue, options such as platelet-rich plasma injections or focused shockwave therapy may support healing.

For cases that do not respond, Dr. Manouel discusses surgical tendon repair when appropriate. Dr. Formica focuses on optimizing non-operative strategies first, tailoring plans to each patient's lifestyle in the Bronx and Queens area. The goal remains restoring function without unnecessary procedures.

Recovery Timelines and What Patients Can Expect

Most individuals see improvement within three to six months when following a structured program. Early phases emphasize pain control and gentle mobility. Later stages introduce progressive strengthening and sport-specific drills.

Full return to heavy lifting or competitive play may take four to nine months depending on severity. Consistent follow-up with the care team helps adjust the plan and prevent setbacks. Patients in Great Neck often appreciate the flexibility of appointments across multiple locations.

Choosing the Right Provider in Your Area

Selecting a practice experienced in both surgical and non-surgical elbow care improves outcomes. Look for physicians who evaluate the entire upper extremity chain and offer coordinated services under one roof. Proximity to Forest Hills, Queens, or the Bronx offices makes regular visits more manageable.

Dr. Manouel and Dr. Formica work closely with patients to set realistic goals and monitor progress. Their combined expertise in orthopedic surgery and sports medicine supports individualized plans that address why pain keeps returning.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does chronic tennis elbow typically last?

Duration varies, yet many patients notice meaningful improvement within three to six months when they follow a consistent treatment plan. Persistent cases may require longer management.

Can I continue playing tennis with this condition?

Modified play or rest periods are often recommended until pain decreases and strength returns. A specialist can guide safe return-to-sport timing.

Is surgery always necessary for recurring elbow pain?

Most individuals improve with non-surgical approaches. Surgery is considered only after thorough evaluation and when conservative measures have not provided relief.

What exercises help prevent tennis elbow from returning?

Eccentric wrist extensions and forearm strengthening performed regularly reduce future strain. Proper warm-up and ergonomic adjustments also play key roles.

How soon should I see a doctor if pain returns?

Contact a provider when symptoms last more than two weeks or interfere with daily activities. Early assessment often leads to simpler treatment options.

Call (718) 897-2228 or visit https://www.msorthovasc.com to schedule an evaluation with Dr. Manouel or Dr. Formica at one of our Forest Hills, Great Neck, or Bronx offices.

Have Questions?

Our team at M&S Vascular and Orthopedic Group P.C. in Forest Hills, Queens is here to help.

Call (718) 897-2228